Alan Fisher - Journalist

Personal website of Al Jazeera English journalist, Alan Fisher

The Blog

Gunning for the Presidency

Posted on September 22, 2011 at 4:35 AM

I've had dealings with Martin McGuinness for almost 20 years. I know his background, I know the stories they tell about him. Yet I find him more human, easier to deal with than his colleague Gerry Adams. Even during the stressful early days of the peace process, McGuinness never lost his sense of humour or easy way with the media.


The decision by Sinn Fein to run him as a candidate in the Irish Presidential election is opportunistic but not surprising.


Senator David Norris was the early favourite. Smart, personable and openly gay he is well regarded in many parts of Ireland but errors of judgement were highlighted and he dropped out of the race.


Once Ireland’s biggest party, Fianna Fail has a formidable political machine across Ireland. It regards itself as the natural party of government but is still recovering after the drubbing it took from the voters in the general election this year. Producing a winning candidate in the Presidential would have been a step in the right direction - but its hamfisted courting of Irish broadcasting legend Gay Byrne and his ultimate rejection of their advances means they won't even field a candidate.


Sensing an opportunity - and Sinn Fein have never been poor at that - the republicans decided they needed a standard bearer and Martin McGuinness would be it. The party has grown in support in the Republic of Ireland in recent years and the number of TDs (Members of the Irish Parliament) and senators stands at 17. Martin McGuinness as the Deputy First Minister in Northern Ireland is an assured political operator. He stands as the anti-establishment candidate and will undoubtedly pick up protest votes in a country still angry at the EU-IMF bailout and the harsh austerity measures imposed to reach tough financial targets.


But he is a former commander in the Irish Republican Army - in charge of one of the most lethal organisations during it’s time of opposition to British rule in the North East corner of the island of Ireland. And so – in the way Kurt Waldheim’s Presidency in Austria was dogged by his links to the Nazi Party – Martin McGuinness will be asked what did he know of what was really going on.


The IRA killed 644 civilians during it’s self styled ’long war‘ against British rule. It killed children in its attacks. It practiced kidnapping and extortion and acts of torture. And it carried out its own style of justice on the streets of Northern Ireland including beatings, shootings and the ‘knee-capping’ of people accused of breaching the rules imposed by the group itself.


For much of this period, Martin McGuinness was thought to be a member of the IRA’s ruling ‘Army Council’. Writer Fintan O’Toole argues in a recent edition of ‘The Irish Times’ that ‘legally and morally, this makes him responsible’. McGuinness has dismissed what he called ‘a media fixation’ on his time on the IRA and says he won’t apologise for the role he played.


The role of President in Ireland is mainly ceremonial – but it would be hugely symbolic if a man regarded by some as a former terrorist and by others as a reason the peace process developed in Northern Ireland gets the top job. His arrival into this new battle will undoubtedly concentrate the minds of the other parties, not least because he is already topping some opinion polls.


Categories: None

Post a Comment


Oops, you forgot something.


The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.

Already a member? Sign In

1 Comment

Reply Robert Wadleigh
7:17 PM on October 12, 2011 
Alan, Sir, I want to thank you for this article. In the days of my youth I had a keen interest in the happenings and ongoing struggles in Ireland. It so often happens that after the news focus shifts away we lose track of the actors/participants. Great to see this article and get further depth and hear what happened. The story is never really over.